Final Fantasy IV Translation Comparison: Loose Ends 1

No Comments

After Cecil and his party return to the surface, the story quickly leads them back underground. But first, maybe it’s best if they share the bad news about everyone who’s died in the past few segments of the game.

No Fooling

Image 1Image 2

The head priest in Mysidia is aware that Palom and Porom turned themselves to stone. So he’s now surprised to learn that Tellah has died too:

Japanese Version (basic translation)English Version
Tella too!? Even after I told him not to fight with so much hatred…Tellah also!? I told him not to fight for hatred alone…
That fool…

The English version of his line is missing the entire second text box in which he calls Tellah a fool. The missing line is so short that I can’t tell if it was cut for memory-saving purposes or if someone on the translation team just messed up.

A strange double-space also appears in the first English text box, almost as if someone edited the translation but didn’t clean up the spacing afterward.

Never Say Die

Image 1Image 2

Yang’s wife responds to news that Yang sacrificed his life for the heroes.

In Japanese, she says something like, “My husband? Don’t be stupid! He’d never die that easily! Never…” In English, however, the translation skirts around the word “die” by saying “gone” and “perished” instead.

And, as we’ve seen before, the English translation doesn’t reflect the wife’s unique speech style.

Missing in Action

Image 1Image 2

Back in Baron, Cid’s daughter asks Cecil a favor and a question – at least in the Japanese version, anyway. She only asks one thing in the English translation.

Japanese Version (basic translation)English Translation
Please look after my father.
He’s been tinkering with airships again, right?Is my father still making airships?

Side-by-side, we can see that the first line was dropped entirely. But why? There are a number of possible reasons, including simple forgetfulness, but the two main reasons that come to mind are:

  • It was done to shave text down to fit within certain memory limitations
  • The missing line uses the Japanese phrase yoroshiku onegai shimasu which is notorious for having a million different possible translations – you can read more about it here. In this case it’s actually pretty easy to translate, but given that this game was mostly translated by a non-native English speaker, it might’ve been clumsy enough that one of the editors decided to cut it entirely later on.

Hovercraft Clarification

Image 1Image 2Image 3

Once back on the surface, Cecil and friends head to Baron Castle and meet with Cid’s apprentices. The apprentices attach a hook to the airship that can pick up the party’s old hovercraft.

Before the apprentices leave, they explain how to grab the hovercraft. The explanation is a little different between the original Japanese release, the Easy Type release, and the English release:

Final Fantasy IV (basic translation)Final Fantasy IV Easy Type (basic translation)Final Fantasy II (Super NES)
You can attach the hovercraft to the Enterprise by moving on top of it and pressing the confirm button!You can pull up the hovercraft by placing the Enterprise’s shadow on top of it and pressing the A Button!To hook or let go of the Hovercraft, press A over the craft.

The change here is pretty simple and understandable – recall that the original Japanese version of Final Fantasy IV lets you reassign buttons and use multiple controllers. This feature was removed from the Easy Type and English versions, presumably to streamline the process and prevent players from accidentally messing up their controller scheme.

As a translator, I personally like how much clearer the instructions are in the Easy Type line. It spells out all the details and offers the player a helpful visible guide.

Just Dying to Die

Image 1Image 2

Before the airship modification scene ends, Cecil tries to tell the apprentices that Cid killed himself. The apprentices interrupt him, though:

Japanese Version (basic translation)English Version
Cecil: Actually, about Cid…Cecil: Cid is…
Apprentice 1: Let me guess, he’s so full of energy that he’s too much to handle?Oh, I can tell you are having trouble handling him. But I won’t blame you! Well, good luck!
Apprentice 2: Yeah, he’s not the kind of guy who’d die even if you killed him!
Apprentice 1: Well, we got a load of work left to do! Good luck out there!

There are three things that stick out in this short exchange.

First, in the Japanese script, it’s clear when a new apprentice line starts – it doesn’t actually list their names or anything, it just shows some “this is the start of a new quote” punctuation. Knowing this, we can see that the apprentice text is made up of three separate lines shared between the two apprentices. Someone on the English localization team didn’t recognize this, though, so now it looks like there’s just one apprentice saying all three lines.

Second, the reference to killing and dying was glossed over and replaced with “But I won’t blame you!”

Third is the actual reference to killing and dying itself: “He’s not the kind of guy who’d die even if you killed him!” If you’re a fan of anime or have been around on the Internet for a while, you might instantly be reminded of these meme-y images:

Image 1

Image 1

Image 1

Image 1

Image 1

This is a sort of set phrase that’s common in Japanese entertainment, and it’s a great example of how literal translations aren’t always the best way to go.

Even without an explanation, you can probably make sense of what this phrase is trying to say. Basically, it makes more sense in translation if you think of it as “staying dead” instead of just “dead”. We have other phrases that fit the bill in English depending on the situation too, like ones involving “nine lives” or “too stubborn to die”. There are so many ways to translate it that I could easily see it being on a translation agency’s test to see how qualified and creative applicants are.

So how did this “he’s not the kind of guy who’d die even if you killed him” line get handled in all the other Final Fantasy IV translations? Let’s take a look!

Image 1Image 2
PSP translation
DS translation
J2E fan translation

Again, we can see how the PlayStation translation lived on for like 10 years in the GBA and PSP translations. In all cases, the actual literal translation was dropped for a more proper English localization.

A Miner Change

Image 1Image 2Image 3

There’s a cave on a tiny little island that couldn’t be accessed until now. Inside are a father and child who collect animal tails. As the kid explains, if you can bring them some rare tails, they’ll give you a rare metal in return.

Final Fantasy IV (basic translation)Final Fantasy IV Easy Type (basic translation)Final Fantasy II (Super NES)
My dad found some strange ore here.My dad found a strange metal here.My dad found a funny ore.
Collecting animal tails is his hobby.Collecting animal tails is his hobby.And you know what? He collects tails!

There’s not much to say about the English translation here. The original Japanese line was updated for Easy Type to use handier formatting and the word “metal” instead of “ore”. The change was probably done with younger audiences in mind.

Treasure Hunting

Image 1Image 2Image 3

A castle in the Eblan Kindom has been destroyed. If you go inside and explore, you’ll find lots of hidden treasure and some tough enemies hiding in treasure chests. These treasures changed between the original Japanese release, the Easy Type release, and the English translation:

Location:Final Fantasy IVFinal Fantasy IV Easy TypeFinal Fantasy II
2FGold NeedleHigh PotionCure 2
2FMaiden’s KissRevive MedicineLife
2FUnicorn HornHeal-All MedicineHeal
2FAlarm ClockHigh PotionCure 2
Right TowerCoeurl Whisker600 Gil600 GP
Right TowerSilver Hourglass800 Gil800 GP
Right Tower 2FEmergency ExitHigh PotionCure 2
Right Tower 2FHermes ShoesRevival MedicineLife Potion
Right Tower 2FBlood LanceBloodthirsty SpearDrain Spear
Left TowerBomb SoulEtherEther1
Left Tower 2F10,000 Gil2000 Gil2000 GP
Left Tower 2FArrows of VoicelessnessSilence ArrowsMute Arrows
Left Tower 2FBacchus’ WineHigh PotionCure 2
BasementSilver AppleElixirElixir

There are so many hidden treasures here that I feel like I might not know about every single one, even after all these years. So it’s possible there’s more to add to this list!

No Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *